top of page
Folio Normal.png

Common Operational Challenges Facing Multi-Academy Trusts (and How to Overcome Them)

Nov 2
5 min read

Managing a Multi-Academy Trust (MAT) brings both opportunities and complexities. From balancing budgets and maintaining staffing levels to ensuring consistency across multiple schools, trust leaders face an increasingly demanding operational environment.

Dark blue Folio Insights slide reading Common operational challenges facing Multi Academy Trusts, with a pink line chart.


As MATs grow, so do their responsibilities. What may have once been manageable at an individual school level can quickly become more complicated when overseeing several academies, each with its own workforce requirements, financial pressures and operational priorities.

Understanding these challenges, and putting effective strategies in place to address them, is essential for building a sustainable, high-performing trust.

Here, we explore some of the most common operational challenges facing Multi-Academy Trusts and the practical steps leaders can take to overcome them.

1. Managing Financial Pressures and Budget Constraints.

Financial sustainability remains a key priority for Multi-Academy Trusts. With rising operational costs, competing investment priorities and growing demands on school resources, trust leaders must continually assess how funding is allocated.

One area where expenditure can become particularly difficult to control is staffing. Unplanned absences, recruitment challenges and reliance on temporary agency workers can all contribute to unexpected costs.

For trusts operating across several academies, a lack of centralised visibility can make it difficult to understand overall workforce expenditure and identify opportunities for savings.

How can MATs overcome this challenge?

  • Introduce centralised financial reporting to improve visibility of expenditure across academies.

  • Review staffing costs regularly, including temporary recruitment and agency expenditure.

  • Consolidate suppliers where appropriate to improve purchasing efficiency and consistency.

  • Develop longer-term workforce plans to reduce reliance on reactive recruitment.

Taking a more strategic approach to resource allocation can help trusts maintain financial stability without compromising educational standards.

2. Recruitment and Workforce Management.

Recruiting and retaining high-quality teaching and support staff is one of the most significant operational challenges facing schools.

For MATs, these challenges are often amplified by the need to manage recruitment across multiple locations, departments and specialist disciplines.

Different academies may have varying staffing needs, while competition for experienced teachers, SEND specialists and support staff can make recruitment particularly challenging.

Without a coordinated approach, trusts may find themselves working with numerous recruitment agencies, managing inconsistent processes and struggling to maintain visibility over staffing expenditure.

How can MATs overcome this challenge?

A centralised workforce strategy can help trusts take greater control of their recruitment requirements.

This could include:

  • Establishing consistent recruitment and compliance processes across all academies.

  • Building talent pools to support recurring and anticipated vacancies.

  • Developing clearer visibility of temporary and permanent staffing requirements.

  • Reducing administrative workloads through streamlined supplier management.

  • Working with a managed service provider to coordinate recruitment activity across the trust.

By moving from reactive recruitment towards proactive workforce planning, MATs can improve staffing continuity while reducing the administrative burden on individual schools.

3. Maintaining Consistency Across Multiple Academies.

Every academy within a trust has its own identity, community and educational priorities. However, maintaining consistent operational standards across multiple schools is essential for effective trust-wide management.

Differences in processes, reporting systems, procurement arrangements and staffing procedures can create inefficiencies and make oversight more challenging.

As a trust expands, these inconsistencies can become increasingly difficult to manage.

How can MATs overcome this challenge?

The key is finding the right balance between centralised oversight and individual school autonomy.

Trust leaders should consider introducing standardised processes for areas such as procurement, HR, compliance and reporting, while allowing schools the flexibility to respond to local needs.

Clear communication between central teams and academy leaders is equally important, ensuring that policies are understood and implemented consistently.

4. Ensuring Compliance and Effective Governance.

Multi-Academy Trusts operate within a complex regulatory environment, with responsibilities covering financial management, safeguarding, employment practices and governance.

The Department for Education's Academy Trust Handbook sets out requirements for financial oversight, internal controls and accountability. Trust leaders must ensure that these obligations are met across their organisation.

When managing multiple academies, maintaining accurate records and ensuring consistent compliance can require significant time and resources.

Staffing introduces additional responsibilities, particularly around safeguarding checks, employment documentation and the suitability of temporary workers.

How can MATs overcome this challenge?

  • Establish clear governance structures and lines of accountability.

  • Conduct regular compliance reviews across academies.

  • Use consistent safeguarding and recruitment procedures.

  • Maintain centralised records and reporting systems.

  • Ensure external staffing partners follow appropriate compliance and safeguarding processes.

A well-structured approach to compliance can reduce operational risk and provide greater confidence to trust leaders, trustees and school communities.

5. Balancing Centralisation with School-Level Autonomy.

One of the biggest management challenges for MATs is deciding which responsibilities should sit with the central trust team and which should remain with individual academies.

Centralising functions such as finance, procurement, HR and recruitment can generate efficiencies and improve oversight. However, excessive centralisation can sometimes create bottlenecks or limit the flexibility schools need to respond to their individual circumstances.

How can MATs overcome this challenge?

Successful trusts establish clear responsibilities and decision-making processes.

For example, a trust may centralise supplier agreements, recruitment standards and budget monitoring while allowing headteachers to determine their school's day-to-day staffing requirements.

This approach provides consistency and control without removing the operational flexibility that individual academies need.

6. Improving Data Visibility and Operational Reporting.

Effective decision-making relies on access to accurate, timely information.

However, MATs may operate across different management systems, reporting platforms and administrative processes, making it difficult to develop a clear trust-wide picture of performance.

This can affect everything from financial forecasting and resource allocation to staffing decisions and operational planning.

How can MATs overcome this challenge?

Trusts should prioritise systems and processes that support centralised reporting and meaningful performance insights.

In workforce management, this might involve tracking:

  • Temporary staffing expenditure across individual academies.

  • Agency usage and supplier performance.

  • Vacancy fulfilment rates and recruitment timescales.

  • Recurring absence patterns and staffing requirements.

  • Compliance and safeguarding documentation.

With greater visibility, trusts can identify trends, address inefficiencies and make more informed decisions about resource allocation.

7. Scaling Operations as the Trust Grows.

Growth can create valuable opportunities for Multi-Academy Trusts, but bringing additional schools into an existing structure also introduces operational challenges.

New academies may have different systems, supplier relationships, staffing arrangements and internal processes.

Without effective integration, this can increase administrative workloads and make it more difficult to maintain consistent standards.

How can MATs overcome this challenge?

Trusts should develop scalable operating models that can accommodate growth without continually increasing complexity.

This includes establishing consistent onboarding processes for new academies, reviewing existing supplier arrangements and ensuring that central teams have the capacity and systems required to support additional schools.

A scalable approach to staffing and procurement can be particularly valuable, allowing new academies to benefit from existing trust-wide processes and relationships.

Building a More Efficient and Sustainable Multi-Academy Trust.

While every Multi-Academy Trust faces its own challenges, many operational pressures share a common theme: the need for greater visibility, consistency and control.

From financial management and governance to recruitment and workforce planning, having the right structures and partnerships in place can make a significant difference.

For many trusts, improving how staffing is managed represents an opportunity to reduce administrative complexity, control costs and allow school leaders to focus more of their time on delivering high-quality education.

How Folio MSP Can Support Your Trust.

At Folio MSP, we understand the challenges of managing staffing requirements across multiple academies.

Powered by Prospero Group, with over 25 years of experience in education recruitment, Folio provides managed staffing solutions designed specifically for Multi-Academy Trusts.

Our approach helps trusts move away from fragmented, reactive recruitment towards a more coordinated and transparent staffing model.

Through a centralised managed service, Folio can support trusts with:

  • Greater control: A more consistent approach to managing temporary staffing and recruitment suppliers.

  • Improved visibility: Clearer oversight of staffing activity, expenditure and supplier performance.

  • Reduced administration: Streamlined recruitment processes that ease the workload on central teams and individual academies.

  • Workforce planning: A more proactive approach to identifying and responding to staffing requirements.

  • Education expertise: Access to specialist recruitment knowledge backed by the wider Prospero Group.

With the right staffing strategy in place, trusts can focus on what matters most: supporting their schools, their staff and their pupils.

Smarter staffing, greater control.

Discover how Folio MSP can support your Multi-Academy Trust at www.foliomsp.com.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page